When Jesse Stone is invited to a reunion in New York of his old Triple-A team, he is forced to grapple with more than just regrets about the play that ended his career. Kayla, his ex-girlfriend and current wife of an old teammate, is there, too. As is Kaylas friend, Dee, who has regrets of her own. Jesses time at the reunion is cut short when, in Paradise, a young woman is found murdered and her boyfriend is missing and presumed kidnapped. Though seemingly coincidental, there is a connection between the reunion and the crimes back in Paradise as it becomes clear that one of Jesses old teammates is involved in the crimes.