After she and her Saddle Club friends return from an enjoyable overnight camping trip with other members of Pine Hollow Stables, Carole is delighted to be given the care of a thoroughbred stallion she's come to love.

When three friends accompany their riding instructor to New York City to attend an important horse show, they meet their favorite actor, who asks them to help him learn to ride for his latest movie.

Corey's pony, Samurai, seems to get spooked every time a pony named Midnight passes by while at a Halloween party.

Corey's pony has run away, and it's up to the Pony Tails to rescue him Corey's newly divorced parents are still working out which days Corey stays with each of them. Most weekends, Corey can be with her beloved pony, Samurai, and hang out with her best friends and neighbors, May and Jasmine. But this weekend, she is going to her dad's, so she has asked her fellow Pony Tails to keep an eye on Samurai. Corey hates to leave, but she knows that no one...

May Grover knows Wil is a bully and a tease and decides it's time to teach him a lesson.

Jasmine feels left out after her baby sister Sophie is born, but when an orphaned foal gets in a jam one afternoon, Jasmine saves the day and realizes that there are advantages to being an older sister.

May is having a horrible day and it seems like nothing is going right, but it only gets worse when she decides to take her pony out for a ride, and her family thinks she has run away.

Ever since Carole's mother died, Carole has been urging her dad to date, but now he's seeing someone she doesn't want for a stepmother. The other members of The Saddle Club are so busy modeling for a riding catalog they can't help.

Lisa is hired to write a weekly column for the local paper, but everyone at the stables becomes furious after her first column is published.

The Saddle Club, including new member Christine come up with a plan to help the Bar None Ranch and their good friend Kate keep the ranch running.